Eklund: Happy New Year! We Will Crown The Best Ever Today. Now...#14-#9

Pronger played less than 200 total games for Philly. Desjardins or Timonen would be better choices, as good as he was.

Also, why do some teams get 4 F and others only get 3?

Pronger played less than 200 total games for Philly. Desjardins or Timonen would be better choices, as good as he was.

Also, why do some teams get 4 F and others only get 3?
- jmatchett383

Yeah, but he completely skipped St. Louis at the time he was actually naming people, just changed the list to throw them in towards the bottom after the fact. So got to get Pronger in other places.

Horrible list at best. 🤢

Bourque more Bruin then Avalanche

You've inserted STL at #19 without including them in your rankings in your 21-16 blog.

Bourque more Bruin then Avalanche
- Snipeclan

He is including the same person on multiple teams. But if Bourque at 40 years old with less than 100 games played for Avs counts him for their team, that means Gretzky should count for St. Louis & NYR, along with a whole host of other amazing players who had short stints with teams. But he isn't using any set rules for who counts where.

Judging by your rules of no rules, why did you pick these guys for the Caps?

#16 Washington Capitals
Backstrom Ovechkin Bondra Johansson Langway Holtby

Jagr has to count as much as Bourque in Colorado. Oates? Gartner? Stevens? Out of all the great defenders the Caps have had, you picked Calle Jo? Wut.

You've inserted STL at #19 without including them in your rankings in your 21-16 blog.
- Yeah Boyes

Gretzky Hull Oates Shanahan Pronger MacInnis Stevens Harvey Hall

Look at the teams he's listing above that group lol. Of course he can't name them at 19, gotta slide it in later. Too few Blues fans have used hockeybuzz since Andy Strickland left for Blues to warrant a higher ranking on any list here.

Desjardins over pronger. No question

WHERE IS SANDIS OZOLINSH!?!?

Rubbish.

A list of Rangers with no Jean Ratelle is just silly. He averaged nearly a point a game over his 21 years with the Rangers.

A list of Rangers with no Jean Ratelle is just silly. He averaged nearly a point a game over his 21 years with the Rangers.
- e11even

This list just shows what a sorry franchise the Rangers are. The Islanders have been around a third of the time and have a better collective group hands down.

No question the pens will top this list with lemieux jagr crosby malkin coffey Murphy and barrasso

Didn’t Richter get his cup when he played for the Oilers in 1994?

Frank Boucher makes the Rangers list 😂😂😂😂

Lindros, Francis, J.P. Parise, Linseman, Leetch, Housley, Kolzig

No question the pens will top this list with lemieux jagr crosby malkin coffey Murphy and barrasso
- Upstate_isles

Goaltending the only question here. Canadiens and Wings will challenge.

Barbumhole over maf? Nah.

Thanks ek ya stupid bastard. Ya skipped right over St Louis. Did Shanny sleep with your wife too?

Barbumhole over maf? Nah.
- ChrisMS

Tom Barazzhole better? Maf over him 11 times outta ten

Goaltending the only question here. Canadiens and Wings will challenge.
- BringNYIhome

Didn't Ek say depth counted? Because I think Pens are weaker there.

List is so whack...

Shouldn't count achievements done on other teams.

Pronger an All Time Flyer????
How many games he play there? If I remember correctly he was more of a contract headache there.

Bourque is an all time Bruin. Roy a Hab.
Bourque was a shell of himself in Colorado

This list is garbage

Oilers? Gretzky, messier, mcdavid , coffee, pronger, fuhr

Still confused how Oates, Gretzky, Hull, Stevens, McInnis, and Fuhr are ranked 19th.